Gas vs Electric Fireplace: Which Is Right for Your BC Home?

When choosing between a gas and electric fireplace, the decision comes down to more than just looks. If you're wondering about the real differences in cost, installation, maintenance, and performance, this blog has your answers. Let's explore the pros and cons of each option, with a clear focus on why Eco Pro Heating specializes in gas fireplace services for North Vancouver and surrounding areas.

1. Heat Output: Which Fireplace Heats Better?

If you're after serious warmth, gas wins. A gas vs electric fireplace comparison always starts with BTUs—the heat output. Gas fireplaces can produce up to 40,000 BTUs, while most electric models cap around 5,000–8,000.

Why it matters: A gas fireplace can heat a large open-concept living space, while an electric model may only handle a small room.

gas vs electric fireplace​

2. Realism and Ambience

There's no mistaking a real flame. If aesthetics matter, the gas vs electric fireplace debate leans heavily toward gas. Gas fireplaces deliver flickering, radiant flames, while electric fireplaces simulate flame with light and projection.

Gas fireplace bonus: You get the ambiance and the heat—no compromise.

3. Installation & Setup

Gas fireplaces require professional installation. That means venting, gas line access, and proper sealing for safety. It's a bigger upfront investment—but also a more permanent, high-performance fixture.

Electric fireplaces can often be plugged in and placed wherever there's a standard outlet. While convenient, they aren't typically a primary heat source.

Tip: If you're looking for a lasting home upgrade, gas is worth the install.

gas vs electric fireplace​

4. Ongoing Maintenance & Safety

When it comes to gas vs electric fireplace maintenance, gas requires more attention—and for good reason. Regular inspections ensure safe operation, proper combustion, and carbon monoxide prevention.

Electric fireplaces require minimal upkeep, with no fuel lines or emissions to worry about.

Important: A neglected gas fireplace can become a safety hazard. Eco Pro offers regular servicing to ensure safety and efficiency.

5. Energy Efficiency and Operating Costs

When comparing gas vs electric fireplace operating costs, it comes down to usage and energy prices in BC.

  • Gas: More expensive upfront, but efficient for heating larger spaces.
  • Electric: Lower upfront cost, predictable energy bills, and easy zone heating.

For supplemental heat, electric is economical. But for consistent, full-room warmth, gas pays off long-term.

gas vs electric fireplace​

6. Environmental Impact

Concerned about emissions? Electric fireplaces don’t produce combustion byproducts. But in BC, where we have clean hydroelectric power, that makes electric fireplaces even more eco-friendly.

However, modern gas fireplaces are far more efficient than older wood-burning stoves and still provide excellent heating without wood smoke.

7. Cost Breakdown: Gas vs Electric Fireplace

Gas Fireplace:

  • Unit Cost: $2,500–$8,000
  • Installation: $1,000–$5,000
  • Annual Maintenance: ~$200

Electric Fireplace:

  • Unit Cost: $300–$2,000
  • Installation: $0–$500
  • Maintenance: Minimal

Verdict: Electric fireplaces win on upfront costs. Gas wins on long-term performance.

gas vs electric fireplace​

8. Why Eco Pro Only Services Gas Fireplaces

At Eco Pro Heating, we specialize in gas fireplace repair, installation, and servicing across North Vancouver because:

  • Gas provides real, reliable heat for cold BC winters
  • Gas fireplaces offer long-term value and home resale appeal
  • Our technicians are licensed and trained in gas line safety

If you’re weighing gas vs electric fireplace options but want heat that performs all winter, gas is the clear winner.

9. Summary Table: Gas vs Electric Fireplace

Feature Gas Fireplace Electric Fireplace
Heat Output High (20,000+ BTU) Low (4,000–8,000 BTU)
Flame Realism Real flame Simulated light
Installation Professional required Plug-and-play
Maintenance Annual inspections Minimal
Efficiency High for full-room heat Best for zone heating
Upfront Cost Higher Lower
Eco-Friendliness Moderate High (BC Hydro)
gas vs electric fireplace​

FAQs: Gas vs Electric Fireplace

Which is better for heating: gas or electric fireplace?
Gas delivers more heat and is better for full-room heating. Electric works best in small spaces.

Are gas fireplaces expensive to run?
They can be, depending on gas prices. But they are efficient for zone heating in cold climates.

Is electric safer than gas?
Yes—electric fireplaces have fewer fire and carbon monoxide risks, but gas is still safe with regular maintenance.

Can Eco Pro install electric fireplaces?
No. We specialize in gas fireplace repair and servicing to ensure safety and reliability for Vancouver homes.

Need Help With Your Heating or Cooling System?

Whether you’re dealing with a stubborn pilot light, a noisy blower, or just want to keep your HVAC system running smoothly year-round — Eco Pro Heating & Cooling has your back.

Explore all HVAC services

See available grants and rebates

Contact us anytime — we’re available 24/7

Back to our homepage

We’ve been proudly serving Vancouver and the North Shore for over 20 years, with 300+ 5-star reviews and a commitment to getting it 100% right — or it’s 100% free. Call us today at (604) 725-4485 or get a free quote and let’s bring comfort back to your home.